Rubrics and Grading

This page includes three types of alternative assessments that may be used in my classroom this year.  The first is a science portfolio.  Following is a rubric outlining how lab reports will be graded.  Please do not use this as a form for a lab report.  This only serves as a guiding outline on how to prepare the report.  The last rubric is an outline of a project rubric detailing how class, group, or individual projects will be graded.  Modifications may be made to this rubric by both the teacher and the students depending upon the actual project.  I hope this helps both you and your parents to understand how some of the grading, in addition to some more traditional forms of grading such as tests, will be conducted.  Please e-mail or call me with questions.

Mrs. Takacs

 Earth Science Portfolio

We will be maintaining a portfolio as an assessment tool in CP Earth Science. This type of evaluation allows for reflection by both teachers and students; it shows changes in your understanding over a period of time. It emphasizes creation and performance, as opposed to knowledge alone.

Each student’s portfolio will be different to reflect the work of the individual; however, the organization will be the same. Your portfolio will be set up as follows:

    1. Cover – Your cover must reflect you in relation to earth science. At a glance, the reader should be able to determine some information about you. It might include photographs showing you involved in some of your favorite activities or hobbies such as rock and mineral collecting, hiking, rafting, sky watching or recycling. You might decorate it with original artwork. It might have a picture of you performing a laboratory experiment in earth science class. It might be a collage of words and pictures which reflect your favorite things. It must say "earth science" and "portfolio" somewhere on it, and it must include your name and the school year.
    2. Table of Contents – this will be a list of the items contained in the portfolio and the page numbers on which they can be found. The table of contents will change throughout the year as you add and discard items in your collection.
    3. Letter of Introduction – You will write a letter which explains each of the entries you have selected, what you learned from each, and the reasons you chose the entry as demonstrating your best science work.
    4. Lab Investigation – you will include a formal lab report that you created, not a form lab report. As with all lab reports, this must include a title, hypothesis, procedure, data section, conclusion, sources of error, and two new things you learned from the exercise.
    5. Video or Library Critique – using any video or scientific literature we used this year, write a critique including the following: an abstract (summary of the material covered), a list of the concepts covered, and an explanation of how the information presented applies to the world around you.
    6. Mixed Media – Choose one of the projects you completed this year (photo journal, model, research paper, etc.) Write an abstract of the project, explain the purpose of the project and the concepts involved, include an evaluation of the project, and include your original write-up of the project.
    7. Integration – using a lab, project, or notebook entry, show how the content applies to other areas of science or other curricular areas. Example: Volcanic eruptions—pyroclastic flow—economic impact of the affected area.

You will maintain your own portfolio during the course of the year in a folder or loose-leaf notebook. All portfolio entries in their final form need to be typed or neatly written in blue or black ink. Please read the entire rubric carefully to ascertain exactly what is required for each level of performance for your portfolio. This is an extremely important representation of your entire year’s efforts, and you should take great pains to ensure that you have given it your best effort. Your portfolio will be graded on a five point rubric. This will reflect your self-assessment, as well as my evaluation of your portfolio. Your portfolio assessment will be recorded as a major grade in the fourth rating period. You may submit items from September until May. They will be collected in mid-May.  The following are rubric guidelines and grades.

 

 

Lab Report Outline and Rubric

Name, date of experiment, title, lab report typed.

2 points – Must include all of the above.

Problem or Task:

2 points – Must be clearly stated and includes background information.

Hypothesis or possible outcome of task:

3 points – It is a potential answer to a problem or potential outcome of a task and is clearly stated.

Materials:

1.

2.

3.

4.

3 points – Must be in a list form, must include all materials.

Procedure:

1.

2.

3.

4.

5 points – Must be in a list form, must include all steps, must be in sequence.

Data : (This could include a table, graph, or chart. Use your "Insert a Table" function in "Word" or create a spreadsheet and create a graph. Here is an example of inserting a table.

                       
                       
                       
                       

5 points – Must include a chart, table, and/or graph. Must include units.

Observations:

1.

2.

3.

4.

5 points – Must be in a list form, must include all pertinent observations, you needed to record this information while conducting the experiment or activity.

Analysis and Conclusions:

In a 4 – 6 sentence paragraph, or more:

  1. Analyze and summarize what happened in the experiment using the data to support your position.
  2. State whether the hypothesis was correct and why or why not and/or state whether your task was completed successfully and why or why not.
  3. Propose an explanation for why the lab activity gave the results that it did. Offer explanations for sources of error.

5 points – Must be in paragraph form, no spelling errors, and a minimum of 4 sentences. Must address the above points clearly. Have someone read your final draft to see if it makes sense.

Practical Applications:

In a three to five sentence paragraph (or more) tell me how the information you gained could be used in real life. Also, tell about and explain at least two new things that you learned.

5 points – If possible, tell how this can be applied in real life. This part requires thinking and creativity. Also, you must include a minimum of two new ideas that you learned.

 

 

 

Project Rubric

Name of your project _______________________________________________________

Parts

  1. Visual Aid / Graphic Representation of your work/research
  2. Must be neat – effort counts

    Lettering is clear, spelled correctly, and large enough to see from across a room

    Must have detail – we should know a lot about your research by "looking"

    No cut and paste – original artwork - art ability not graded / effort is

    Be creative!

    Neatness        10  9  8 7 6   5  4  3  2  1

    Detail/Effort 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12à

  3. Paper –
  4. 2 pages

    Size 12 font

    Double spaced

    1-inch margins

    3 references minimum

    List Internet source addresses – I will check them

    No cut and paste on any writing!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (-20 points)

    Paper 25 24 23 22 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 à

  5. 1 Class Hand-out
  6. You need to provide 1 hand-out for each person

    5 questions that the class needs to answer from your presentation

    Not much writing

    You want them to listen and remember 5 most important ideas

    This paper must be turned in by due date – I need time to copy!!!!!!!!!!!

    Quality of handout/On time 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0

  7. Verbal presentation

Eye contact

2 minutes

Clear speaking voice

No um,uh,etc./Little reliance on notes/few pauses

         2 minute presentation 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0

     5.  In class time and effort 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0

Must be prepared to work the entire period during each work session

Bring art materials

Be prepared to type or do research on computer – however, have an alternate task

Be prepared to prepare note cards

Be prepared to practice oral presentation

Loss of most points for first time not prepared for entire period!

Total Points __________ / 100

09/17/02

frogrun.gif (1825 bytes)