Internet Types Rate The 2004 Toronto Film Festival
Key (and links to commentary where applicable):
MD= Mike D’Angelo
AF= Alex Fung
EG= Erik Gregerson
SH= Skander Halim
JH= Jeremy Heilman
AJ= Andrew Johnston
DM= Don Marks
VM= Victor Morton
OO= Omar Odeh
CO= Charles Odell
DO= Dan Owen
TP= Theo Panayides
JRP= J. Robert Parks
ZR= Zach Ralston
JR= Joshua Rothkopf
MiS= Missy Schwartz
MS= Michael Sicinski
CS= Chris Stults
ST= Scott
Tobias
3.50 Sideways (4.0 AJ, 4.0 JR, 4.0 ST, 3.5 DM, 3.0 ZR, 2.5 MD)
3.33 Kung Fu Hustle (4.0 EG, 3.5 MS, 3.5 DM, 3.0 JR, 3.0 ST, 3.0 MD)
3.13 La Femme de Gilles (3.5 DO, 3.5 VM, 3.5 EG, 3.5 CS, 3.0 AF, 3.0 CO,
2.5 JH, 2.5 MD)
3.11 Keane (3.5 TP, 3.5 ST, 3.5 CS, 3.0 MiS, 3.0 VM, 3.0 DM, 3.0 CO, 3.0
DO, 2.5 MS)
3.11 Tropical Malady (4.0 TP, 4.0 CS, 3.5 OO, 3.5 MD, 3.5 JRP, 3.0 VM,
3.0 EG, 3.0 MS, 3.0 DO, 3.0 ST, 2.5 DM, 2.5 CO, 2.5 JR, 2.5 SH)
3.07 House Of Flying Daggers (4.0 DO, 4.0 EG, 3.0 JRP, 3.0 CO, 2.5 MD,
2.5 AF, 2.5 SH)
3.07 I Heart Huckabees (4.0 DO, 3.5 AJ, 3.5 MD, 3.0 ST, 3.0 JRP, 2.5 TP,
2.0 JR)
3.05 Kings And Queen (4.0 JR, 3.5 CS, 3.5 ST, 3.0 SH, 3.0 VM, 3.0 TP, 3.0
CO, 2.5 OO, 2.5 MS, 2.0 MD)
3.00 Duck Season (3.5 TP, 3.0 MS, 3.0 MD, 3.0 JH, 2.5 JRP)
3.00 The Holy Girl (3.5 JR, 3.0 OO, 3.0 TP, 3.0 ST, 3.0 JH, 3.0 MD, 3.0
JRP, 3.0 MS, 3.0 MiS, 2.5 DM)
3.00 Primer (4.0 MD, 3.5 ST, 3.5 DO, 3.0 JR, 3.0 AJ, 3.0 TP, 3.0 CO, 3.0
MiS, 2.5 DM, 2.5 OO, 2.0 VM)
3.00 Tarnation (3.5 ST, 3.5 TP, 3.0 CO, 2.5 MD, 2.5 EG)
3.00 3-Iron (3.5 MD, 3.5 ZR, 3.5 VM, 3.0 AF, 3.0 TP, 3.0 JH, 3.0 CS, 3.0
ST, 3.0 MS, 3.0 DM, 3.0 CO, 2.5 JRP, 2.0 JR)
2.95 Nobody Knows (4.0 VM, 3.5 JR, 3.5 AF, 3.0 ST, 3.0 TP, 3.0 JRP, 3.0
AJ, 2.5 MS, 2.0 MD, 2.0 ZR)
2.93 The World (3.5 EG, 3.0 JR, 3.0 ST, 3.0 CS, 3.0 OO, 2.5 MD, 2.5 TP)
2.92 Bad Education (3.5 ZR, 3.0 JR, 3.0 VM, 3.0 ST, 3.0 MD, 2.0 DO)
2.88 The Assassination Of Richard Nixon (3.5 VM, 3.0 SH, 2.5 TP, 2.5 AF)
2.88 P.S. (3.5 AJ, 3.5 CO, 3.0 JR, 3.0 ST, 2.5 DM, 2.5 MD, 2.5 ?, 2.5 VM)
2.86 The Motorcycle Diaries (4.0 AJ, 3.5 JRP, 3.0 DM, 3.0 DO, 2.5 VM, 2.0
MD, 2.0 JH)
2.81 10th District Court: Moments of Trial (3.5 JR, 3.0 TP, 3.0 ST, 3.0
MS, 2.5 MD, 2.5 JRP, 2.5 CS, 2.5 SH)
2.79 Stray Dogs (3.5 VM, 3.5 JRP, 3.5 MiS, 3.0 ZR, 2.5 MD, 2.0 JH, 1.5
JR)
2.75 Cinevardaphoto (3.0 JR, 3.0 JH, 3.0 JRP, 3.0 CS, 2.5 MD, 2.0 OO)
2.75 The Raspberry Reich (3.0 OO, 3.0 MS, 2.5 JH, 2.5 VM)
2.72 Café Lumiere (3.5 OO, 3.5 JRP, 3.5 EG, 3.0 JR, 3.0 MS, 2.5
ZR, 2.0 MiS, 2.0 AF, 1.5 VM)
2.70 Clean (3.5 AJ, 3.5 JH, 3.0 VM, 3.0 TP, 3.0 ST, 3.0 DO, 3.0 CO, 2.5
OO, 2.5 MS, 2.5 MD, 2.5 CS, 2.5 JR, 2.5 EG, 2.0 JRP, 1.5 AF)
2.69 Old Boy (4.0 ZR, 3.5 ST, 3.5 DM, 3.0 TP, 3.0 MiS, 3.0 MD, 3.0 DO,
2.5 EG, 2.5 CO, 2.5 MS, 2.0 JH, 1.5 JRP, 1.0 JR)
2.67 Calvaire (3.5 DO, 3.0 DM, 3.0 CO, 2.5 MD, 2.0 MS, 2.0 JH)
2.67 Mysterious Skin (3.0 ZR, 3.0 ST, 3.0 CO, 3.0 TP, 2.0 MD, 2.0 JH)
2.67 Our Music (3.5 MS, 3.0 SH, 3.0 JH, 3.0 OO, 3.0 EG, 3.0 TP, 2.0 MD,
2.0 JR, 1.5 CO)
2.64 Whisky (3.0 CO, 3.0 MD, 3.0 MS, 2.5 JRP, 2.5 TP, 2.5 MiS, 2.0 JH)
2.63 Breaking News (3.5 DO, 3.5 EG, 3.0 JH, 3.0 CO, 2.5 OO, 2.0 MS, 2.0
MD, 1.5 AF)
2.63 Cinq Foix Deux (5X2) (3.5 TP, 3.0 AF, 3.0 ST, 3.0 DO, 2.5 VM, 2.5
JR, 2.5 ZR, 2.5 JH, 2.5 JRP, 2.5 SH, 2.0 CO, 2.0 MD)
2.63 The Woodsman (3.5 DM, 3.0 AJ, 3.0 DO, 2.5 ST, 2.5 CO, 2.5 JR, 2.0
TP, 2.0 AF)
2.60 Five (3.0 OO, 3.0 SH, 2.5 JRP, 2.5 MS, 2.0 JH)
2.60 My Summer Of Love (3.0 CO, 3.0 SH, 3.0 AJ, 2.5 JH, 1.5 JRP)
2.50 The Machinist (3.0 DM, 3.0 DO, 2.5 AF, 2.5 AJ, 1.5 JR)
2.50 Millions (2.5 ST, 2.5 MD, 2.5 TP, 2.5 AF, 2.5 ZR, 2.5 JR)
2.50 Mondovino (3.0 JH, 2.5 MS, 2.5 AJ, 2.0 MD)
2.50 Les Revenants (3.5 EG, 2.5 ST, 2.5 JR, 2.5 DM, 2.5 AF, 2.0 MD, 2.0
VM)
2.50 A Tout de Suite (3.0 VM, 2.5 JR, 2.5 ST, 2.5 JRP, 2.5 CO, 2.5 MD,
2.0 AF)
2.50 Yes (3.0 MS, 2.0 JH)
2.42 L’Intrus (3.5 OO, 3.5 JRP, 3.0 MS, 3.0 CS, 3.0 JH, 2.5 DM, 2.5
DO, 2.5 MiS, 2.0 ST, 1.5 CO, 1.5 MD, 1.5 AF, 1.5 JR)
2.40 Kinsey (2.5 AJ, 2.5 ST, 2.5 MD, 2.5 JH, 2.0 AF)
2.40 Private (3.5 TP, 2.5 OO, 2.0 MD, 2.0 CS, 2.0 AJ)
2.38 Moolaade (3.0 JH, 2.5 EG, 2.0 MD, 2.0 TP)
2.38 9 Songs (3.0 AJ, 3.0 DM, 3.0 JRP, 3.0 AF, 2.5 JR, 2.5 ST, 2.5 JH,
2.0 TP, 2.0 CO, 2.0 DO, 1.5 MS, 1.5 ZR)
2.38 Schizo (3.0 JRP, 2.5 DM, 2.0 MS, 2.0 JH)
2.38 Steamboy (3.0 DM, 3.0 CO, 2.0 DO, 1.5 EG)
2.36 Zebraman (3.0 DM, 3.0 EG, 2.5 MD, 2.0 MiS, 2.0 DO, 2.0 JH, 2.0 VM)
2.33 Innocence (3.0 DM, 3.0 MD, 2.0 CO, 2.0 JH, 2.0 CS, 2.0 AJ)
2.33 The Phantom Of Henri Langlois (2.5 JH, 2.5 CS, 2.0 TP)
2.31 Undertow (3.0 VM, 2.5 AF, 2.5 CO, 2.5 DO, 2.5 MD, 2.0 DM, 2.0 JR,
1.5 JRP)
2.30 Tomorrow We Move (3.0 TP, 2.5 CO, 2.0 MD, 2.0 AF, 2.0 JR)
2.29 Throw Down (3.0 ZR, 2.5 SH, 2.5 DO, 2.5 JH, 2.0 DM, 2.0 EG, 1.5 CS)
2.25 The Heart Is Deceitful Above All Things (3.0 SH, 3.0 JH, 2.5 OO, 2.0
AF, 1.5 MD, 1.5 MiS)
2.20 Palindromes (3.0 JR, 3.0 DO, 3.0 ST, 3.0 DM, 2.5 SH, 2.5 TP, 2.0 MS,
2.0 AF, 1.0 JRP, 0.0 VM)
2.17 Vital (3.0 VM, 2.0 DM, 2.0 CO, 2.0 DO, 2.0 MD, 2.0 JH)
2.14 Enduring Love (3.0 AJ, 2.5 TP, 2.5 MD, 2.0 DM, 2.0 AF, 1.5 JH, 1.5
ZR)
2.13 Kontroll (3.0 JRP, 2.0 ST, 2.0 DM, 1.5 JH)
2.13 Lila Says (3.0 JH, 2.0 DO, 2.0 AF, 1.5 CO)
2.10 A Dirty Shame (3.0 JH, 3.0 VM, 2.5 DO, 2.0 JR, 0.0 ZR)
2.08 Ghost In The Shell 2 (2.5 JH, 2.5 EG, 2.0 SH, 2.0 MD, 2.0 VM, 1.5
CS)
2.08 When Will I Be Loved (2.5 CO, 2.0 ST, 2.0 DO, 2.0 MD, 2.0 JH, 2.0
AF)
2.07 Eros (2.5 MD, 2.5 MiS, 2.5 JH, 2.0 OO, 2.0 ST, 2.0 CO, 1.0 JR)
2.00 Low Life (2.0 JRP, 2.0 CO, 2.0 EG, 2.0 VM)
2.00 Ma Mere (3.0 MS, 2.0 SH, 1.5 DO, 1.5 VM)
1.88 Land Of Plenty (2.0 MD, 2.0 MS, 2.0 JH, 1.5 OO)
1.88 Los Muertos (2.5 MS, 2.0 ST, 2.0 JR, 1.0 MD)
1.86 The Sea Inside (3.0 AF, 2.0 ST, 2.0 MD, 2.0 JH, 1.5 TP, 1.5 JR, 1.0
ZR)
1.83 Anatomy Of Hell (2.5 MS, 2.0 AF 2.0 ST, 2.0 CO,1.5 JR, 1.0 MD)
1.83 Dead Man’s Shoes (2.0 MD, 2.0 JH, 1.5 CO)
1.82 A Hole In My Heart (3.0 JR, 2.5 DO, 2.5 JRP, 2.5 JH, 2.0 AF, 2.0 MD,
2.0 TP, 1.5 ST, 1.0 CO, 1.0 CS, 0.0 VM)
1.80 10 On Ten (3.0 JRP, 2.5 SH, 2.0 JH, 1.5 OO, 0.0 MD)
1.75 Saw (2.5 DM, 2.5 JH, 2.0 JR, 2.0 MD, 1.5 ST, 1.5 AF, 1.0 CO, 1.0 TP)
1.69 After The Day Before (3.0 EG, 2.5 AF, 2.0 SH, 2.0 DM, 1.5 DO, 1.5
CS, 1.0 OO, 0.0 VM)
1.63 Automne (2.0 MS, 2.0 AF, 1.5 DO, 1.0 JH)
Films Seen By Fewer Than Four Participants:
4.00 Line Describing A Cone (4.0 JRP)
3.75 Skagafjordur (4.0 JRP, 3.5 MS)
3.50 Downfall (3.5 TP)
3.50 Ferpect Crime (3.5 EG)
3.50 I Died In Childhood (3.5 EG)
3.50 Imaginary Heroes (3.5 DO)
3.50 In My Father’s Den (3.5 DO)
3.50 Touch The Sound (3.5 JRP)
3.50 Vento di Terra (3.5 DO)
3.33 The Forest For The Trees (3.5 MD, 3.5 JR, 3.0 AF)
3.25 Forgiveness (4.0 EG, 2.5 OO)
3.00 Darwin’s Nightmare (3.0 JRP)
3.00 Double Dare (3.0 EG)
3.00 Earth And Ashes (3.0 JRP)
3.00 The Last Victory (3.0 CO)
3.00 La Noire De (3.0 OO)
3.00 On The Outs (3.0 JRP)
3.00 Our Own (3.0 EG)
3.00 Quill (3.0 MS)
3.00 Spider Forest (3.0 CS, 3.0 TP)
3.00 Unforgivable Blackness (3.0 VM)
3.00 A Way Of Life (3.0 DO, 3.0 VM)
2.75 Child Star (3.0 ZR, 2.5 AJ)
2.75 Hotel Rwanda (3.0 SH, 2.5 MD)
2.67 The Merchant Of Venice (3.0 VM, 2.5 CO, 2.5 EG)
2.50 Antares (2.5 MD, 2.5 JH)
2.50 Boats Out Of Watermelon Rinds (2.5 JRP)
2.50 Le Cou de la Girafe (2.5 JH)
2.50 Crash (3.5 AJ, 1.5 JH)
2.50 Creep (2.5 DM, 2.5 DO, 2.5 JH)
2.50 Dear Frankie (2.5 AF)
2.50 Free To Go (Interlude) (2.5 MS)
2.50 Going Upriver: The Long War Of John Kerry (2.5 ST)
2.50 A Good Woman (3.0 VM, 2.0 AF)
2.50 Harvest Time (2.5 EG)
2.50 The House Keys (2.5 JH)
2.50 Off Beat (2.5 OO)
2.50 Omagh (2.5 ST, 2.5 MD, 2.5 JR)
2.50 Pour La Suite Du Monde (2.5 CS)
2.50 Seven Times Lucky (2.5 SH)
2.50 Stage Beauty (2.5 AF)
2.50 Trilogy: The Weeping Meadow (3.5 VM, 2.0 MS, 2.0 OO)
2.50 Two Great Sheep (2.5 DM)
2.50 Unconscious (2.5 EG)
2.50 Whale Of A Tale (2.5 DM, 2.5 CO)
2.50 Year Of The Yao (2.5 ST)
2.50 Z Channel: A Magnificent Obsession (3.0 EG, 2.5 DO, 2.0 AF)
2.33 Rahtree: Flower Of The Night (2.5 JH, 2.5 TP, 2.0 DM)
2.33 Turtles Can Fly (3.5 JRP, 2.0 MS, 1.5 JH)
2.25 Astronauts (3.5 EG, 1.0 JH)
2.25 Bluebird (3.0 JRP, 1.5 AF)
2.25 L’Equipier (2.5 AF, 2.0 VM)
2.25 Promised Land (2.5 OO, 2.0 AF)
2.17 Final Cut: The Making And Unmaking Of Heaven’s Gate (2.5 ST,
2.0 JH, 2.0 JR)
2.17 Silver City (2.5 DM, 2.0 JRP, 2.0 MD)
2.16 Brodeuses (2.5 CO, 2.0 JH, 2.0 AF)
2.00 Blood (2.0 TP)
2.00 Brothers (2.0 JH)
2.00 Buffalo Boy (2.5 DM, 1.5 JRP)
2.00 Casuistry: The Art Of Killing A Cat (2.0 JR)
2.00 Chased By Dreams (2.0 DM)
2.00 Dead Birds (2.5 DM, 2.0 EG, 1.5 JH)
2.00 Dias De Santiago (2.0 ST, 2.0 JR)
2.00 Letters To Ali (2.0 OO)
2.00 Head In The Clouds (2.0 ST, 2.0 JRP, 2.0 ZR)
2.00 Ray (2.0 MD, 2.0 AF, 2.0 AJ)
2.00 Shake Hands With The Devil (2.5 SH, 1.5 AF)
2.00 Shark Tale (2.5 CO, 2.0 VM, 1.5 ST)
2.00 Wilby Wonderful (2.0 CO, 2.0 DO)
1.83 Small Mall (2.0 SH, 2.0 DO, 1.5 CS)
1.75 Human Touch (2.0 AF, 1.5 CO)
1.50 Beyond The Sea (1.5 MD)
1.50 Days And Hours (1.5 JH)
1.50 The Libertine (1.5 AF)
1.50 Midwinter Night’s Dream (1.5 TP)
1.50 My Father Is An Engineer (2.0 MD, 1.0 AF)
1.50 Niceland (1.5 JH, 1.5 TP)
1.50 Oyster Farmer (1.5 JRP)
1.50 La Peau Blanche (1.5 DM, 1.5 CO)
1.50 The Tuner (1.5 EG)
1.25 Rolling Family (1.5 MD, 1.0 MS)
1.00 Cool (1.0 CS, 1.0 TP)
1.00 Five Children And It (1.0 CS)
1.00 Haven (1.0 AF)
1.00 Scared Sacred (1.0 VM)
1.00 Sucker Free City (1.0 JH)
0.50 Theme Je (1.0 OO, 0.0 JH)